Sunday, January 24

That was almost a play. Almost.


I am a big Nick Hornby fan. I read HOW TO BE GOOD in two and a half days. I used a monologue from A LONG WAY DOWN for auditions for years. His screenplay for AN EDUCATION was brilliant. I am currently reading his latest, JULIET, NAKED. And I am also a fan of his most popular novel, HIGH FIDELITY.

This book (of which there is also a film adaptation) was turned into a Broadway musical in 2006. A Broadway musical, which ran for only 10 days. Which surprised me, because it had so many great things going for it: music by Tom Kitt, a quality cast, and good creative team. Casting by Telsey + Company. ; )

So when I heard there was a company doing the Canadian premiere of the show, I figured I had to see it. If no reason than to see just why the show didn't work. (Also, I should note that I am going to be on a ship for eight months, and will see no plays during that time, so I am just trying to see as much theatre as I can beforehand...) So last night, David and I bravely made our way to the show, just to see what all of the fuss was about.

There were some things I liked. The fantasy elements where were funny. And the script does a good job of taking the novel's theme of "desert island top 5 favorites" and employing it throughout the show.

But for all of those pluses, there are more things that just don't click. The lyrics, while they fit the jaded characters, provide more exposition than character exploration. And there is a surprisingly amount characters TELLING us how they feel, rather than ACTUALLY feeling it. There is only so much I can take of performers standing on the lip of the staging and belting at me about their situations. I'd rather they turn to each other and act like they are communicating.... But maybe that's just me.

I should also note that this was a college production, so it was probably not the best interpretation of the piece. Certainly, these were not the best actors for these roles, nor was the design particularly conducive to the telling of the story.

In the end, I just don't think the show works. You empathize with the characters, but don't really know why. And I rarely felt like I understood why I should. It has all of the pieces of a musical, without the coherence that makes a great musical.

But I figured, when am I ever gonna get a chance to see this show again. So I saw it. And it was almost a musical comedy. Almost.

No comments:

Post a Comment